Serving Brooklyn, Queens and Long Island(929) 429-2429Open six days a weekFree estimateGuaranteed work
On Point Garage Doors
Open 24 hours Sun-Thu, Fri until 5 pm Free estimate Springs, openers, cables We come to you
Emergency?Call nowBook free estimate
New York, NY - open six days a week

Clopay vs Amarr garage doors

Free estimateSame-day serviceCommon parts on board
  • Free estimate
  • Same-day service
  • Common parts on board
Emergency garage door repair★★★★★ 5.0 on Google · 42 reviews

Book your free estimate

Takes 30 seconds. We call you back to set a time.

Or just call (929) 429-2429 and talk it through.

Home › Clopay vs Amarr

Clopay and Amarr are two of the best-known American garage door makers, and a lot of homeowners narrow their choice down to these two before they call us. Both make a wide range of steel doors, carriage-house styles and wood-look finishes, with several levels of insulation. The honest answer is that both make good doors, and the line you pick inside a brand matters more than the name on the label. This page sets out how they compare in plain words, so you can go into the estimate knowing what to ask. We install and repair both brands across Brooklyn, Queens and Long Island. Free estimate at (929) 429-2429.

By Sean Cohen, owner, On Point Garage Doors · Updated

Real jobs. Real photos.

These photos are from our own jobs, with our logo on them.

An old door before replacement, from one of our jobs
An old door before replacement
Two new wood-look doors on a stone house, from one of our jobs
Two new wood-look doors on a stone house
Garage under the stoop of a brick house, from one of our jobs
Garage under the stoop of a brick house

Who they are

Clopay is one of the largest makers of residential garage doors in North America and is sold through dealers and home stores. Amarr is a long-running American maker that sells mainly through dealers. Both have been making doors for a long time, both stand behind their products, and both are common enough in our area that parts for the main lines are not hard to get.

Styles side by side

Both brands offer traditional raised panel doors, flat modern steel, carriage-house designs with decorative handles and hinges, and full-view glass doors. Clopay's best-known lines include Classic, Coachman, Canyon Ridge and Modern Steel. Amarr's include Heritage, Lincoln, Hillcrest, Classica and Oak Summit. If you have a particular look in mind, chances are both brands have something close to it.

Insulation and strength

Each brand makes doors from a single sheet of steel up to sections with steel on both sides and foam in between. Clopay uses a poured foam it calls Intellicore in some lines. Amarr offers both foam boards and poured foam depending on the line. A door with steel on both faces and foam in the middle is stiffer, quieter and better at keeping the garage comfortable, which matters most when there is a room above or beside the garage.

Wood-look finishes

Both brands make steel doors that look like stained wood, and both have improved a lot in recent years. Clopay's Canyon Ridge line uses a composite overlay that looks very close to real wood. Amarr's wood-look lines use embossed steel and printed finishes, and Oak Summit is a common choice for a carriage look. The best way to choose is to see a sample in daylight next to your front door and trim.

Windows and decorative options

Window inserts, glass types and decorative hardware are available on most lines from both brands. The choices differ in the details: the shape of window frames, the number of designs and the colors on offer. We bring brochures and samples so you can see what each brand offers on the style you like, rather than choosing from a small picture online.

How they hold up near the water

Salt air is hard on any steel door. What protects a door here is the paint system on the steel, the quality of the hardware and how well the door is sealed. Both brands use galvanized steel with baked-on finishes. On houses close to the bay or the ocean, we suggest a thicker steel skin, a door with steel on both sides, and stainless or coated hardware where the line offers it.

The install matters more than the label

A good door put in badly will be noisy, drafty and hard on the opener. A plain door put in well will run quietly for years. Correct springs for the weight, straight tracks, a solid header and a level bottom seal decide how the door actually works day to day. When you compare estimates, ask what is included in the install, not just which brand is on the door.

Springs and the opener

A heavier insulated door from either brand needs stronger springs than a light one, and the springs have to be sized to the exact door. If you are keeping your opener, we check that it can handle the new door's weight and height. Both brands work with all the common openers, so the brand of door does not decide the brand of opener.

Repairs on Clopay and Amarr doors

We repair both brands every week: springs, cables, rollers, hinges, seals and damaged sections. Matching a section is easier on a current line than on a door that is many years old, because colors and patterns change. If your door has a label inside, the line and date help us find the right part.

So which one should you pick

Pick the door whose style, insulation and finish suit your house best, from whichever brand makes it. If two doors are close, look at the details: window options, colors and the hardware. We have no reason to push one brand over the other. Our job is to put in the door you choose and make sure it works well for a long time.

What the estimate includes

We measure the opening, the headroom and the side room, look at the frame and the floor, and go over styles and finishes from both brands. You leave with a clear written estimate for the door you choose, including the install, the springs and anything the opening needs.

Questions we get asked

Is Clopay or Amarr better?

Neither is better across the board. Both make good doors; the line, the insulation and the install matter more than the brand.

Which brand has more wood-look options?

Both have several. Clopay's Canyon Ridge looks very close to real wood, and Amarr's Oak Summit is a popular carriage look. Seeing samples side by side helps most.

Do you install both Clopay and Amarr doors?

Yes. We install and repair both brands across Brooklyn, Queens and Long Island.

Which brand is better near the water?

Either can work. What matters is steel on both faces, a good finish and coated or stainless hardware where the line offers it.

Is the estimate free?

Yes. We measure the opening and give you a written estimate for the door you pick.

Booking takes a minute

Across Brooklyn, Queens and Long Island, tell us what the door is doing and we set a visit that fits your day.

Free estimate, call (929) 429-2429.

Deciding between brands? We will bring samples

Tell us what the door is doing and we will give you an honest arrival time. The estimate is free.

Easier to explain by phone? Call (929) 429-2429.

Two minutes to a free estimate

Tell us what the door is doing. The estimate is free either way.

Or just call (929) 429-2429 and talk it through.

The other six things that go wrong